New York Giants

Position	Name	OVR
QB	E. Manning	87
QB	R. Bomar	62
QB	D. Carr	60
QB	J. Lorenzen	38

RB	B. Jacobs	90
RB	A. Bradshaw	73
RB	A. Brown	71
RB	D. Ware	66

FB	M. Hedgecock	87

WR	S. Smith	76
WR	H. Nicks	76
WR	D. Hixon	70
WR	R. Barden	66
WR	M. Manningham	63
WR	S. Moss	60

TE	K. Boss	83
TE	D. Johnson	69
TE	T. Beckum	69

OL	C. Snee	97
OL	S. O’Hara	91
OL	D. Diehl	88
OL	K. McKenzie	88
OL	R. Seubert	87
OL	W. Beatty	76
OL	G. Whimper	73
OL	A. Koets	69
OL	K. Boothe	66
OL	M. Fladell	64

DL	J. Tuck	95
DL	O. Umenyori	94
DL	M. Kiwanuka	85
DL	C. Canty	84
DL	F. Robbins	83
DL	R. Bernard	80
DL	B. Cofield	75
DL	J. Alford	65
DL	D. Tollefson	60

LB	A. Pierce	86
LB	M. Boley	82
LB	C. Sintim	74
LB	D. Clark	74
LB	Z. DeOssie	72
LB	B. Kehl	64
LB	J. Goff	59
LB	C. Blackburn	69

CB	C. Webster	90
CB	A. Ross	81
CB	K. Dockery	76
CB	T. Thomas	67
CB	D. Wright	63

S	K. Phillips	78
S	M. Johnson	74
S	C. Brown	70

K	L. Tynes	66

P	J. Feagles	87

Share:

{ 85 comments… read them below or add one }

Mike June 23, 2009 at 4:39 pm

Cory Webster a 90? kind of pushing it don't you think.

holywar June 29, 2009 at 12:40 am: no

Reply
dkr July 12, 2009 at 2:18 am: maybe a little but Ross is better the Webster

Reply
Mblock July 19, 2009 at 8:47 pm: i agree cory Websters 90 is way over rated

Reply
AndyMac July 24, 2009 at 1:01 am: Madden always pushes it for the giants, or else they would be rated 70 overall every year

Reply

bdog giants rule June 25, 2009 at 2:27 pm

i know eli struggled in the postseason last year but they shouldnt rate him a 87 hes way better than that these ratings stink

dkr July 12, 2009 at 1:48 am

i agree only 87 McNabb 90 joke Eli should be 92-94 and McFagg 74 at best

AndyMac July 24, 2009 at 1:01 am

manning is a fuckin joke he should be rated less than 80

Jinx August 9, 2009 at 5:40 am

Eli struggled that the end of the year. Cutler throw for more yards and had a better passer rating and he had the same rating. Hell he had passed for less yards than Pennington, about the same as M.Ryan and has a better rating. He not good and this year will show it, as well Brandon Jacobs is over rated he's not that good especia;;y with the new rating system he needs to be a 88 maybe

Chris August 9, 2009 at 5:45 am: eli suks straight up

Reply

tom shaver August 14, 2009 at 10:48 am

look at Eli's career QB rating. No he's not better than an 87

Jon K. June 28, 2009 at 1:12 pm

Eli should be like a 92 or something and Kevin Boss.. bbring those ratings up . Also Michael Boley a 82 he's a beast. Bring it up on all of the ratings. Cause right now their ratings are no more than a few fat kids fighting for candy. They just suck o.k.

Jon K. June 28, 2009 at 1:14 pm

David Carr is better than a 60. And give the kickers and punters some credit for every team almost.

tom shaver August 14, 2009 at 10:35 am: David Carr is much better than a 60. These people aren't doing there homework.. My question is, How can they rate Ahmad Bradshaw a fucking 73 when he averaged 5.3 yds. per carry last year albeit in limited action, and Bradshaw was very instrumental in the Giants Super Bowl victory against the Patriots. He actually had a lot better numbers than Jacobs in that game. These ratings are fucking garbage. Bradshaw has done enough in his short career to deserve some fucking respect. Bullshit

Reply

Eaglesfan June 29, 2009 at 3:10 pm

Obviously i am an eagles fan but i have to say something, why in the world would EA make Jared Lorenzen a 38? don't even bother putting him in the game! that is awful!

John Madden himself July 2, 2009 at 7:18 pm: yeah he'd probably be rated higher as an Offensive lineman…..

Reply
mark503 August 13, 2009 at 10:37 pm: ant that the truth

Reply

BigBlue219 June 30, 2009 at 3:03 am

why on earth did EA put Corey Webster as a 90 and Aaron Ross as an 81??? I mean I love em' both but c'mon everyone knows that Aaron Ross is better then Corey Webster!!!! and even if Corey was better he's definitley no that much better! If anything their ratings should be flipped around.

Eaglesfan July 1, 2009 at 1:34 am: Well consider yourself lucky to have two solid starting cornerbacks when most teams don't even have one. Besides, an 81 with this new rating system is like a high 80 in madden 09 so both will be very good players in madden 10, don't be to concerned.

For a good laugh take a look at the falcons CB corp, its pathetic. It will make you feel like the giants have the best CB corp in the league, they are all very talented, but there not quite the best.

Reply
dkr July 12, 2009 at 2:10 am: yes Ross is better and Tynes is better than 66 mabye not much but he is better more like a 73

Reply
Real G Men fan August 17, 2009 at 12:56 am: if Aaron is better why is Corey normally assigned to the other teams best WR, did you not watch the Giants Superbowl run in the playoffs!!!!!!!

Reply

Luke June 30, 2009 at 4:12 am

Haha wow most overrated team in the game

LOL June 30, 2009 at 7:58 pm: Most overrated? Come on Luke deep down in your heart you don't even believe that. I also feel Carolina is still underrated. How does #1 rushing O, 5th overall defense, top 9 in every other major catgory counts as overrated. The Cards are underrated, the Dolphins, Jets, and Redskins are underrated too. Chargers are overrated.

Reply
dkr July 12, 2009 at 2:12 am: ha screw you go back to Romo and those Cowgrils

Reply

Luke June 30, 2009 at 4:16 am

How is Eli manning as good as Tony Romo. If you look at their stats Tony Romo's worst season is better than Eli Manning's best. doesn't make sense. Also jacobs is not a 90, that is ridiculous.

Nicholas July 1, 2009 at 12:55 am

Tony Romo is a gay asshole thats why.

dkr July 12, 2009 at 1:59 am

i agree Romo sucks but McNabb 90 wtf it should be Eli 992-94 Romo 87 Campbell 79 McNabb 74 and that is giving NcFagg a gift

tom shaver August 14, 2009 at 10:47 am: McNabb is a very good QB and that rating is fair. Just because you hate him doesn't mean he aint good, and I am a Giants fan.

Reply

Chris August 9, 2009 at 5:44 am

i agree

Chris August 9, 2009 at 5:44 am

wait i agree wit the guy named luke. romo is the best QB in the NFL in my mind

tom shaver August 14, 2009 at 10:45 am: Tony Homo always chokes on a big fat dick in big game situations. The best QB's in the NFL don't do that

Reply

Donovan August 11, 2009 at 1:59 pm

tony romo blows cock. that dude was born with hands wrapped around his neck

tom shaver August 14, 2009 at 10:44 am

I have to agree with you about Eli with the exception that Eli has won a Super Bowl and Tony Romo always chokes in big game situations. And I totally disagree with you about Jacobs. His career ave. yrds per carry is 4.7 and in each of the last two years he's averaged 5.0. How many other backs in the league can say that? Do some research on that question and then reassess your statement about Jacobs. Look at the running backs that you think are better than him and compare their yards per carry.

LOL June 30, 2009 at 11:35 am

Actually I think Jacobs is better than a 90, and Eli should be an 89. He had over 3,000 yeards and only like 10 interceptions thrown. The Giants players indiviually are underrated. Corey Webtster was one of the best corners in the league last year with 4 picks, Ross has 3, they had the #1 rushing offense, the 5 best overral defense, and they were top 9 in almost every major category in the league. This is the second year in a row that the Giants were blatantly disrespected and the second straight year that the Pats didn't win the Superbowl are still rated the best team. Overall the Giants should be a 90 if not for the defense alone.

John Madden himself July 2, 2009 at 7:20 pm

yeah Romo should be around 81.

Grandma's boy July 2, 2009 at 7:23 pm

Wow the Giants have INCREDIBLE depth on the D-line.

Broncos fans must weep when they see the giants ratings

Ryan July 2, 2009 at 9:14 pm

The one rating on the DL I would argue is wrong is Bernard. He should be rated lower. Seattles two starting DT's last year were Bernard and Mebane. Mebane had 5.5 sacks while Bernard had 4. Madden rated Mebane a 71. Bernard a 80. The sticking point of my arguement is that Mebane was working out of the 2 gap while Bernard was working in the 3 tech. The 3 tech is the guy who is supposed to colapse the pocket and pressure the QB, translating into more sacks. The 2 gap is supposed to draw a double team and take two blockers out of the play. So what does it say about Bernard that the guy demanding double teams got more sacks last year than the guy in a one on one situation to pressure the QB up the middle? It says he is over the hill and not deserving of the 80 ranking. Bernard was a 83 in Madden 09, so he only had a three point drop in ratings. Many other good players suffered a lot bigger drop under the new rating system. IMO he should be dropped into the 70's or atleast should be lower than Mebane. Sometimes strait up compairisions do not make for a good way to rate players but I think Madden had it wrong here.

KA1Z3R July 9, 2009 at 9:22 pm

actually the plan in Seattle was to have two run stopping DT while using two pass rushing DE's on the edge.

Ryan July 15, 2009 at 6:22 pm: Then why does every coach and media member in Seattle talk about how moving Mebane from the 2 gap to the 3 tech this year and the effect it will have? If there was no difference in the two positions why even mention it? If you were a Seattle fan, I might try to see your point, but since you have spent I am guessing about 1/100 of the time I have following the team if that, it is a hard sell. Holmy did not technically call the two DT positions different but Bernard was working with one on one blocking while Mebane consistantly got doubled.

Reply

Anthony July 3, 2009 at 8:26 pm

typical bullshit pierce is one of the most underrated players in the NFL look I dislike pierce he is probably my least favorite player on the team but i still think he should be a 89 not a 86

dkr July 12, 2009 at 2:21 am: true but i bet they lowered his stats a little because of his age

Reply

Rap July 8, 2009 at 5:08 am

Kevin Boss is an 83 and Dustin Keller is a 77??? thats crazy… Boss is no where near the pass catcher Keller is… Keller had better stats last year even with Favre firing picks left and right and splitting time with Chris Baker… Hes a better athlete too… they both arent very good blockers, id give the edge to Boss but not by much but Kellers such a superior athlete and pass catcher that theres no way he should be rated lower than Boss… that just dont make sense to me… give Keller an 80(if he could block would be like mid 80s) and Boss should be like a 75-77… in the new ratings system that seems right… And to back this up look at the 2008 stats which these ratings are based on… Kevin Boss 33 catches for 384 yards and Dustin Keller 48 catches 535 yards… they both averaged about 11 yards a catch…

superdynamite July 31, 2009 at 4:50 pm: Boss has the softest hands in the league, won a superbowl and is a top 10 pass blocker. Keller doesn't block because he can't. The truth is the JETS could have picked keller in the 4th round. Instead, the perennial loser organization and management of the JETS used their first round pick on a TE, leaving Kenny Philips, Donnie Avery, Eddie Royal, Matt Forte & Ray Rice on the board. Blithering idiots.

Actually, the JETS could have probably signed Keller when the draft was over. Another wasted pick.

2009 AFC EAST Standings
#1. Pats
#2. Miami
#3. Bills
#4. Jets

Reply

Fred July 9, 2009 at 1:45 am

how can you say webster isnt a 90?!? he shut down every #1 reveiver on every playoff team 2 yrs ago.
Bucs: Galloway, Cowgirsl: Owens, Packers: Driver and he did as good as any 1 can against Moss

Arron Ross is good but not like Webster. Ross got smoke like rolled weed by Bralon Edwards

dkr July 12, 2009 at 2:24 am

true Ross is slower but i think he a smarter as well

superdynamite July 31, 2009 at 4:54 pm: Actually, Ross is faster. Webster plays his angles better.

Reply

superdynamite July 31, 2009 at 4:53 pm

Webster's rating should be 93. Ross should be 91.

Not only did the G-Men shut down all the top WRs, but they also smacked ARIZONA and pounded PITT last year. The two superbowl teams.

Horrible ratings on Madden 2010. Not only the Giants. Horrible rating for all the teams.

colton July 11, 2009 at 6:05 am

eli manning…. HIS NAME SHOULD MAKE HIM A 92 LET ALONE HIM WINNING A SUPERBOWL!! come on EA…. i know you dont want to push the envelope with making teams too powerful based on one season (even though the pats didnt make the playoffs! and are 93 overall) but come on! boss is better than that too

dkr July 12, 2009 at 2:06 am: yea Madden hates the G=Men they were the worst team in the NFC East after wining the SuperBowl and Jacobs sould be like 94

Reply
........... August 6, 2009 at 12:48 am: manning is right where he should after that pitiful performance in the playoffs hell get a higher rating if he proves he can win without burress

Reply

dkr July 12, 2009 at 1:51 am

i think Hixon is the Gians best WR he should be like 82

Ryan July 15, 2009 at 6:31 pm: EA seems to use draft order to rank players for the most part. The top three guys are Curry J Smith and Crabtree at 85 and 84. Maybe if they drafted him in the top ten he would be ranked 82. Or was a top ten prospect. Being that he was a late first early second prospect, I would say the rating is about where it should be.

Reply
JohnnyX July 30, 2009 at 2:50 am: hixxon is NOWHERE near the giants best recievers… if i had to order them:

1. Steve Smith
2. Hakeem Nicks (based on college, he played in an NFL-styled offense)
3. Mario Manningham (Just as fast as HIxxon but with MUCH better hands and big play ability)
4. Sinorice Moss (sleeper BIG time, he was our best WR in OTA's)
5. Dominik Hixxon (fast but can't catch)
6. Ramses Bardem (he'll be like plax, he'll suck ass for 4-5 seasons but then hit stride, and because of his 6'6 stature he'll catch a lot of balls for Eli, eli missis high, and due to the winds at the meadow lands he'll need a jumper)

Reply

LOL July 16, 2009 at 11:08 pm

Adn that offensive line is terribly underrated. I bet Brady has a fortress around him. Let's give EA a round of applause for another blatant and obvious screwed up

Chief July 18, 2009 at 3:45 pm

These ratings are too rough, they should be higher.(Steve Smith- 76?, Bradshaw- 73?, Tynes- 66??)

DolFan 316 July 19, 2009 at 1:29 am

Wow, the guy ranting about Bernard really knows his stuff Of course another solution would be to rank Mebane higher, which is what I'd have done.

jason July 20, 2009 at 3:56 am

idk what you guys are bitchin about? im finally happy with the ratings eli does need to be bumped down a couple though like come? are yall serious n 87 is generous but other than that everything is perfect…..the past maddens overated to many players they finally doin sumtin right by making superstars superstars and average guys average you guys really needa go to nfl.com and learn your stats haha!!!! 87 for eli to low lmao you guys are jokesters im not a giants fan but even i know your quarterbacksTRASH even with an elite reciver in plaxico look at mcnabb for example never had an elite reciever except one year and ALWAYS puts up nice numbers he deserves his 90 rating

JohnnyX July 30, 2009 at 2:54 am

Eli is technically is still a young QB, his brother and his father were slow learners also, theyre first 4-5 seasons were good, and they did well, but it wasn't until their 5th 6th and 7th season that they started doing well… give eli 1 or 2 more seasons and let him get some good targets to throw to… Only had a few seasons with plax…. No quarterback in the history of the game was good in their first few seasons, dont sleep on eli, he was already in the browbowl. =]

tom shaver August 14, 2009 at 11:10 am: I like Eli but your a dummy. Peyton won rookie of the year in his 1st season and in his 2nd he threw for over 4000 yards and had a 90.7 QB rating. Eli's highest was last year at 86.4. You should research the facts and know a little bit about what your talking about before you make such bold " I know it all ", statements.

Reply

tom shaver August 14, 2009 at 11:04 am

What about Bradshaw's 73 rating? explain that one to me because I cant seem to understand how a RB that averaged 5.3 yards a carry last year and was instrumental in the Giants Super Bowl victory 2 years ago could be rated so low.

alex July 22, 2009 at 7:49 am

smith, ross, bradshaw, hixon, and pierce were snubbed and didn't the giants cut lorenzen like last year

suck eagle nuts July 22, 2009 at 5:28 pm

eli will drop 200 points after the first game
with out his boyfriend plaxico

norm October 11, 2009 at 3:23 am: real brite…..u need a football education

Reply

AndyMac July 24, 2009 at 1:04 am

jacobs, hedgecock, snee(exspecially), tuck, and umenyori are all overated

gfanallday July 24, 2009 at 1:48 am: you have absolutely no idea of what you are talking about jacobs is a freak of nature a guy whos that big and powerful that can run a 4.4 or 4.5 and he rushed for 1100 yards and 15 td hedgecock is one of the best blocking fb in the league snee is the giants best ol on a team that lead the league in rushing and all tuck did was take his game to the next level while losing strahan and osi………you need to do some research on football before you make stupid comments like that

Reply

tony July 24, 2009 at 4:05 pm

andymac how are tuck and osi over rated 2 years ago osi made the probowl and tuck made it this past year and also snee the best line in the league wasn not just 4 guys it takes 5 and hedgecock blocked for ward jacobs and bradshaw and making them 3 great so your retarted

bdog knows this shit July 24, 2009 at 8:59 pm

andymac tell me how jacobs hedgecock and tuck osi snee are overated because last year the giants won the nfc east because of those guys osi was injured if he wasnt the giants would of gone further. andy mac you dont know football fuCkyou

Jimmy July 28, 2009 at 1:27 am

Honestly…all of the WRs that low? At least Nicks should be an 80 and Steve Smith an 80 – 84.

........... August 6, 2009 at 12:52 am

ya beacuse the rookie has proven himself he should be a little lower and smith the # 3 from last year should be 83 which is above average if the new rating system ya that makes alot of sense………..

tom shaver August 14, 2009 at 10:58 am: Don't be surprised if Nicks doesn't do shit this year. He's already missed some of training camp with an injury and rookie WR's need all the practice they can get.

Reply

tom shaver August 14, 2009 at 10:55 am

Why should nicks be an 80? WTF has he done in this league to deserve an 80? Manningham was a 1st round talent and would have gone in the 1st round last year but he lied to NFL teams about getting caught smoking pot so he fell to the Giants in the 3rd round. Does that make him a bad player? Manningham was as good of a college player as Nicks, why shouldn't he be an 80? You people don't do your homework. Every Giants fan should know these facts. Everyone just expects their teams 1st round draft pick to come in and be a lights out world beater every year. Duh

JohnnyX July 28, 2009 at 8:08 pm

First of all the Giants O-Line was the number one rated in the NFL, Everyone should be between 90-97. Kareem McKenzie let up only 9 sacks last season, and hes an 88? Steve Smith is MUCH better than a 76.. atleast and 83… Hakeem Nicks? Was projected to go further in the draft than Jeremy Maclin, Maclin gets an 83 and Nicks gets a 76? Did EA see his crazy behind the back catch in traffic last season? Kevin Boss deserves a much higher rating than 81, atleast 87… Dudes a beast, and ANTONIO PIERCE AN 86?! WTF?! he was a 96 in 09. EA seriously messed the Giants up… Jacobs is atleast a 94, he rushed for 1100+ last season along side Ward who also rushed for 1000+ yards OBIVIOUSLY THEYRE BETTER THAN THEY ARE RATED… Arron Ross is not better than C Webb BTW, but hes atleast an 87-89. Osi?! a 94?! ROFL atleast a 98… he's the next Strahan. And Kenny Phillips is MUCH better than a 76, he was an 83 in 09 as a fucking ROOKIE. EA messed up badly.

superdynamite July 31, 2009 at 4:27 pm

Horrible ratings for a team that wins the toughest division in football year after year, Beat the big bad mighty undefeated Patriots in the Superbowl & Beat the two Superbowl teams last year.
Giants 21 – PITT 14. (Pounded)
Giants 37 – ARI 29 (Smacked!)

The RB ratings are laughable. For those of you that don't watch Football, the GIANTS have had the top rushing attack over the last 3 years.

The G-Men had the MOST comeback wins in the league last year. Thanks Eli!!! You are rewarded with a crappy rating. LOL

FYI: According to EA, the GIANTS have the worst receiving core in the league.

It's all topped off with the most dominant punter in the league getting a big fat 87. LOL

brandon August 1, 2009 at 6:13 pm

its hard to belive in the giants super bowl season they had tuck osi and strahan thats just frikin insane right there i wouldnt want to be a Qb playing against the giants

cowboys fan August 3, 2009 at 6:47 pm

How are the Giants fans are doing to day I want to now one thing how is Giants beeter then the Eagles if beet you fucking cok suckers in playoff last year. And jacobs is overated fat fuck suck and you all now it witout number WR you ant shit and good suck a BIG DICK!

jay August 6, 2009 at 3:17 am

yo to all yall people who just watch one team and dont watch actually football yall need to shut the fuck up and start watchin actuall football to see that some of these ratings are perfect and alot of them are horrible corey webster easily had one of the best seasons for a corner last year, his worst game he only gave up 5 catchsfor 78 yards and that was against the leagues arguablly the best wide reciever larry fitzgerald so shut the fuck up

bob smith August 10, 2009 at 7:02 pm

man look at that DL the giants have this year. coefield, bernard and robbins and canty should be a give a few more points with their rankings. hixon also could have been given a better rating.

zach August 14, 2009 at 11:40 pm

justin tuck is WAY overrated. He had an above average year last year at best, and now he's better then Usi. That is a complete load of bull.

Damien Rowley August 16, 2009 at 7:24 am

I used to have the pride of calling myself a Cowboys fan but keeping Wade Phillips around made me lose my faith. But anyway the cowboys have had underachieving Chris Canty on our team since we drafted him and it has killed me. He is rated 84 on this game that is disgusting the guy is terrible he should be rated in the 60's. And Cory Webster is ridiculously over rated by the way good luck this year Eli you'll need it with that recieving core hopley that loser tyree will clean up your shit again. Phillies going to kill you this year.